Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[demonflair]

Thanks. I thought it was a bit blurred as well, but I also thought I could get away with it. :lol:
I will update a better version next.

Good

Do you like my current sig??

 

[Byuakuya]

Good

Do you like my current sig??

I knew I forgot to do something in my last post....
Now I know it was to comment on your Sig.
Yeah its great. I like the background but I think the render is a bit out of shape. Stretched out maybe?

 

[demonflair]

I knew I forgot to do something in my last post....
Now I know it was to comment on your Sig.
Yeah its great. I like the background but I think the render is a bit out of shape. Stretched out maybe?

Everyone says it... I can't fix it, or maybe I can... but I don't know how...

 

[Foxy]

Everyone says it... I can't fix it, or maybe I can... but I don't know how...

When the rende ris on a layer just scale that layer.

thats how i change size of my renders on gimp anyway.

 

[Byuakuya]

Everyone says it... I can't fix it, or maybe I can... but I don't know how...

The render is placed on an another layer right? If so, then simply select the layer and then re-size it accurately using Shift + Alt while you re-size.

 

[demonflair]

The render is placed on an another layer right? If so, then simply select the layer and then re-size it accurately using Shift + Alt while you re-size.

Nope, still remains with the stretched render :\

 

[Byuakuya]

Nope, still remains with the stretched render :\

Do you have the extracted render saved as a file? Bring that back into the background. Thats the way I usually re-do a massive mistake. By placing the render which I have saved separately.

 

[demonflair]

Do you have the extracted render saved as a file? Bring that back into the background. Thats the way I usually re-do a massive mistake. By placing the render which I have saved separately.

Nah, that's not the problem, it's because it is a GIF file, I can't do anything about it... :\

 

[ssbb_lover]

*cough*

C'mon guys, I know it's bad...but is it so bad you can't critique it? :X

 

[Stranger]

*cough*

C'mon guys, I know it's bad...but is it so bad you can't critique it? :X

not bad, but some of your colors are a little to bright, so they make those sections stand out to much, i guess i should say it looks a little over sharpened.

7/10. not horrible. but not the most amazing of your works.

 

[ssbb_lover]

not bad, but some of your colors are a little to bright, so they make those sections stand out to much, i guess i should say it looks a little over sharpened.

7/10. not horrible. but not the most amazing of your works.

Lol, I would give a 6/10...but one point higher aint to bad either. :] The sig was supposed to turn out a hell of a lot better, dunno what happened...

 

[Stranger]

ok. but btw, after my luck with my kirby sig i had this weird urge and all this inspiration to do a spiderman sig,

heres what i got:

and:

ya i know, theres 2!!

but i like them both because of the different moods that they set.

any critique?

 

[ssbb_lover]

ok. but btw, after my luck with my kirby sig i had this weird urge and all this inspiration to do a spiderman sig,

heres what i got:

and:

ya i know, theres 2!!

but i like them both because of the different moods that they set.

any critique?

The 1st one is...different. Text is "okay", but not bad is the main thing. Nice: 8/10

2nd didn't take near as much work (it doesn't look like), text is so much better however. 7/10

Bad news, the borders on both suck (especially the one in your second sig) . :lol: Just do the three easy choices that I put in my tutorial, or look on the net to see if you find any others that you like. I specifically suggest the "cinematic effect" in my current (as well as many other people's sigs), looks real good with near everything. :]

 

[Stranger]

The 1st one is...different. Text is "okay", but not bad is the main thing. Nice: 8/10

2nd didn't take near as much work (it doesn't look like), text is so much better however. 7/10

Bad news, the borders on both suck (especially the one in your second sig) . :lol: Just do the three easy choices that I put in my tutorial, or look on the net to see if you find any others that you like. I specifically suggest the "cinematic effect" in my current (as well as many other people's sigs), looks real good with near everything. :]

ya, ok, I'll go edit them. :lol: I'm already working on my next one, after that first one a few days ago I'm having all these awesome ideas.

 

[demonflair]

I made two sigs:

My entry in SOTW 6

Made for Mr. Resi