Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[Monsteroids]

Here two variants to a sig I tried making: :/

and:

oh I changed the text colour on the second sig here:

More critique from Demonflair?

 

[Monsteroids]

I chose this 3 sigs to be your best ones

The first sig looks good, but that text :\
You need some text tutorial...

The second would be cool if the border and the text were black instead of blue IMO, the rest of the sig is good

The third needs more work in the background, render on the left is out of proportion, and you don't need the render in the right side of the sig...

The reason the third is bad is because I'm not that good at cutting textured characters out myself. The second, I'm now working on another version.

The first, can you recommend me to some good GIMP friendly tuts?

 

[Byuakuya]

*cough*

C'mon guys, I know it's bad...but is it so bad you can't critique it? :X

Sorry man, we got carried away with our conversation. :lol:
Yeah, I would also give it a 7/10. The Sig is cool but it does look kind of bright. The background is great, as usual. Its not your best work, but a great piece nonetheless.

 

[demonflair]

Here two variants to a sig I tried making: :/

and:

oh I changed the text colour on the second sig here:

More critique from Demonflair?

Definitely the second one is the best one

For improvements in the second sig, first you need to add contrast to the renders and bg, also some lightings, I see you have three renders in the bg... if I were you, I would play with them, using filters, some glass, displace, noise, blurs, wind, and so many other things... also add blending options in those renders, keep in mind that the main render, the centered one, needs to be the most visible and noticed, for that, move the left one a bit to the corner, make it a little bit small (maybe the same size as the other render in the bg) and then make the centered one much bigger...

The reason the third is bad is because I'm not that good at cutting textured characters out myself. The second, I'm now working on another version.

The first, can you recommend me to some good GIMP friendly tuts?

You will find a thread by Brawny in the Design Lounge that has good GIMP tutorials.

I hope that you work a little bit in the second sig, because that was a really good one :]

 

[dan99iel]

This Gimp user is switching to Photoshop. It was inevitable really. My older sister is a University student so i got the CS3 package for $300 AUS.

Package includes:

Adobe Photoshop CS3
Adobe In-Design CS3
Adobe Illustrator CS3
Adobe Device Central CS3
Adobe Bridge CS3
Adobe Stock Photos CS3
Adobe Acrobat 8 Professional

Pretty good huh?

 

[demonflair]

This Gimp user is switching to Photoshop. It was inevitable really. My older sister is a University student so i got the CS3 package for $300 AUS.

Package includes:

Adobe Photoshop CS3
Adobe In-Design CS3
Adobe Illustrator CS3
Adobe Device Central CS3
Adobe Bridge CS3
Adobe Stock Photos CS3
Adobe Acrobat 8 Professional

Pretty good huh?

Sweet

You now must be pretty excited making new sigs with the CS3 version...

 

[ssbb_lover]

This Gimp user is switching to Photoshop. It was inevitable really. My older sister is a University student so i got the CS3 package for $300 AUS.

Package includes:

Adobe Photoshop CS3
Adobe In-Design CS3
Adobe Illustrator CS3
Adobe Device Central CS3
Adobe Bridge CS3
Adobe Stock Photos CS3
Adobe Acrobat 8 Professional

Pretty good huh?

You little sob....lol. Well, good for you. I expect to see your skills rise drastically though!

 

[Foxy]

You little sob....lol. Well, good for you. I expect to see your skills rise drastically though!

Your putting to much pressure on him:lol:

I made a BG this morning, gonna add text and maybe a render if i can find one later:



Currently busy working out mario strikers:lol:

 

[ssbb_lover]

Your putting to much pressure on him:lol:

I made a BG this morning, gonna add text and maybe a render if i can find one later:



Currently busy working out mario strikers:lol:

The depth in it is good....but it's very....boring. :/ Looks like when you leave your computer on for too long and those random pipes start shooting up all over your screen. :lol: I can't really tell you to do anything to it, as there is nothing to do....but it's going to be hard to find a render that goes with it...:/

Long story short, I think pipes are annoying.

 

[Brawny]

LOL, I know what tutorial you used for that..........

@ Dani99el......that just made me the best (imo) gimp user? unless there is a guy who I don't remember.

 

[ssbb_lover]

LOL, I know what tutorial you used for that..........

@ Dani99el......that just made me the best (imo) gimp user? unless there is a guy who I don't remember.

And that makes Dan the best CS3 user. :/

 

[Brawny]

w00t, post 2222.......

Isn't cs3 on torrent yet?

 

[Foxy]

The depth in it is good....but it's very....boring. :/ Looks like when you leave your computer on for too long and those random pipes start shooting up all over your screen. :lol: I can't really tell you to do anything to it, as there is nothing to do....but it's going to be hard to find a render that goes with it...:/

Long story short, I think pipes are annoying.

Your just jelous cause I'm playing mario strikers:lol:


Brawny, C & C on my background a few posts up please.

 

[Brawny]

would make a good matrix sig?

is this the one you used?

http://www.gimptalk.com/forum/topic/Another-Tech-Tutorial-1089-1.html

I like it.....needs render and text badly

 

[Foxy]

would make a good matrix sig?

is this the one you used?

http://www.gimptalk.com/forum/topic/Another-Tech-Tutorial-1089-1.html

I like it.....needs render and text badly

I used that tutorial, then i wanted to make one by myself so done it

I learned that technique from the tute, but thats not my results of following the tute, my results are some big blue thing:lol: