Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[demonflair]

Hah, my ass. Thanks though.

Tbh, i'm sure the effort put into it was great, but just by looking at the sig, it's very boring. Dull colors, no render...text is cool though. That definitely keeps it alive, which is interesting considering you usually don't do that well in that department. GJ. :]

A thing though, why do you always but that big thick line that's a different lighting then the rest of the sig? It's a bit annoying, it looks okay on some of your sigs, but it's sort of old. :/

Meh... I don't have any good ideas for this week's topic... :\


Anyway, here's a sig I made for MYSELF, it's about time I make something for me huh?? And it is my third sig with video animation

Please, some comments and critics would be nice

 

[Stranger]

OMG. It is complete.

My Masterpiece:

Critique?

 

[ssbb_lover]

Meh... I don't have any good ideas for this week's topic... :\


Anyway, here's a sig I made for MYSELF, it's about time I make something for me huh?? And it is my third sig with video animation

Please, some comments and critics would be nice

The render's a bit stretched, but other than that it's actually pretty sorta really cool. :] 8/10

OMG. It is complete.

My Masterpiece:

Critique?

BRANDON!!!!! YOU FINALLY BROKE OUT!!!!!

Seriously man, your 1st good sig, GJ! Render's great, text is great, but the bg is a bit blurry. It looks good blurry, but try making it less blurry.

w00tw00t for Brandon! :] 8.5/10 (best rating i've ever given you)

 

[demonflair]

The render's a bit stretched, but other than that it's actually pretty sorta really cool. :] 8/10

Maybe because it is a GIF file, they sometimes look like that... :\
With video animation, it doesn't support JPEG file, which always looks good, without those stretched things...

 

[Stranger]

BRANDON!!!!! YOU FINALLY BROKE OUT!!!!!

Seriously man, your 1st good sig, GJ! Render's great, text is great, but the bg is a bit blurry. It looks good blurry, but try making it less blurry.

w00tw00t for Brandon! :] 8.5/10 (best rating i've ever given you)

thnx!!

i could tell it was good becuase when i finished i was thinking, dude, it looks like someone good at making sigs made this. :lol:

so ya, any other idea for it?

btw, ever had any new ideas for mock-up thingys that i should make?

 

[ssbb_lover]

thnx!!

i could tell it was good becuase when i finished i was thinking, dude, it looks like someone good at making sigs made this. :lol:

so ya, any other idea for it?

btw, ever had any new ideas for mock-up thingys that i should make?

Nope, i'm also not entering SOTW #6...and I picked the topic. :lol: Sorta sad.

I'm just not getting ideas for "tech". I am making a new sig though (for mahselph), dunno how it will turn out though. :/

 

[ssbb_lover]

w00t, done wid da' sig. :]

Rate and critique, please and thank you. :]

 

[Monsteroids]

I just started using GIMP so my sigs aren't as amaaazing as all of yours.

I used this once

Dun care if he uses it or not

My second or first?

My old avy:

 

[demonflair]

I just started using GIMP so my sigs aren't as amaaazing as all of yours.

I used this once

I chose this 3 sigs to be your best ones

The first sig looks good, but that text :\
You need some text tutorial...

The second would be cool if the border and the text were black instead of blue IMO, the rest of the sig is good

The third needs more work in the background, render on the left is out of proportion, and you don't need the render in the right side of the sig...

 

[Foxy]

More artists who are better then me:lol:

what makes it worse is that he use's gimp just like me:lol:

Im still a beginner i should improve soon.

 

[Byuakuya]

There are more and more artists appearing every single day. This is a good sign. :lol:

 

[demonflair]

There are more and more artists appearing every single day. This is a good sign. :lol:

Yeah, which means the site is getting much better in grafics

 

[Byuakuya]

Yeah, which means the site is getting much better in grafics

Exactly. Everything is going as planned. The Design section is attracting new members like bears to honey.

 

[demonflair]

Exactly. Everything is going as planned. The Design section is attracting new members like bears to honey.

I think that this is a great section, always with 4 or 5 members watching it, and 11 guests... it's becoming great!!!

BTW good sig Pras :]
A bit blurred in the render, but good

 

[Byuakuya]

I think that this is a great section, always with 4 or 5 members watching it, and 11 guests... it's becoming great!!!

BTW good sig Pras :]
A bit blurred in the render, but good

Thanks. I thought it was a bit blurred as well, but I also thought I could get away with it. :lol:
I will update a better version next.