Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[Close]

Tbbh (to be brutally honest), demon...I really don't like the sig. It just isn't anything special IMO. I think you need to learn to stop making your sigs too complicated, sometimes simple is better. You don't have to put a million brushes, then render > [blank] every single render differently and what not....the color also seems a bit boring and I don't exactly love the text. :[

Sorry dude. :/

Tbbh (to be brutally honest)

Spoiler

Demon, I think you might wanna look up some tuts, they can help anyone by a lot.
Most of the sigs you make don't really have a good text usually bad, so you could look up a text tutorial.
Most of your sigs do not have a good bg, mostly below good, but some are great, but to improve you could look up a tutorial.


Sorry dude. :/

 

[Stranger]

ok, did some more work on my sotw 6 entry. heres what ive got now:

critique?

 

[Byuakuya]

3rd, Byuakuya. For the 1st time, I think this sig really does need a border. The text is good, the spatter technique looks a little strange (kind of looks like you sharpened it...), the render placement is nicely done. Not one of your best, but not bad. :]

Thanks man. For the first time ever, I have added a simple border to one of my Sigs to test it out (Tyler's suggestion of course).

 

[Foxy]

Byuakuya, you could enter your current sig into SOTW couldnt you? Its Kos-Mos so technically its Tech.

I shall work on a new project today after a few days of not making stuff due to illnes >.<

 

[Brawny]

I know this is off-topic of this thread, but my interwebs is down at home. Might not be able to get back on for a few days. Just an explanation

Hopefully I can get this SOTW in before the deadline. ^.^

 

[Foxy]

Brawny :]

You shall be missed.

Forget about sotw.

I got the win covered

 

[Byuakuya]

Byuakuya, you could enter your current sig into SOTW couldnt you? Its Kos-Mos so technically its Tech.

I shall work on a new project today after a few days of not making stuff due to illnes >.<

I don't want to rush into things yet. I feel that my skills can be improved greatly before I enter SOTW. Maybe much later.

 

[demonflair]

I made this for some other member:

 

[Stranger]

ok, i really need someone's opinion on this:

i also just finished this for a member named Shoko:

 

[ssbb_lover]

ok, i really need someone's opinion on this:

i also just finished this for a member named Shoko:

The tech sig looks as if almost nothing was done to it...render + border + text. :/

The Brawl one looks like you duplicated the snake render multiple times, motion blurred it for your bg, added 2 renders, then added text. And sorry, but the snake render is terrible resolution. :[

#1 sig: 7/10

#2 sig: 6/10

Sorry buddy. :[

Rate this, I made it really quickly for a tutorial (which can be found here: http://www.wiichat.com/design-lounge/27665-photoshop-beginner-intermediate-tutorial-only-compatible-v-7-cs3.html), but I wanted to see what members would think of it. :]

 

[Stranger]

Rate this, I made it really quickly for a tutorial (which can be found here: http://www.wiichat.com/design-lounge/27665-photoshop-beginner-intermediate-tutorial-only-compatible-v-7-cs3.html), but I wanted to see what members would think of it. :]

k. thnx for the opinion.

Naruto sig = 8/10.

its good, i like the bg. and the glow effects that were used. and the brushes. :lol:

thats alot of things. so it gets and 8/10

keep up the good work.

 

[ssbb_lover]

k. thnx for the opinion.

Naruto sig = 8/10.

its good, i like the bg. and the glow effects that were used. and the brushes. :lol:

thats alot of things. so it gets and 8/10

keep up the good work.

Heh, you could follow the tutorial and make one. :]

:lol:

Might be good for you (and i'm not just pointing out you, i'm talking to all other intermediate GFX artists as well) just to learn a few techniques from. Who knows. :yikes:

 

[Shadow20074]

tyler is some sort of god :O

 

[demonflair]

I made this for SOTW 6:

Comments and critics, please??

 

[ssbb_lover]

tyler is some sort of god :O

Hah, my ass. Thanks though.

I made this for SOTW 6:

Comments and critics, please??

Tbh, i'm sure the effort put into it was great, but just by looking at the sig, it's very boring. Dull colors, no render...text is cool though. That definitely keeps it alive, which is interesting considering you usually don't do that well in that department. GJ. :]

A thing though, why do you always but that big thick line that's a different lighting then the rest of the sig? It's a bit annoying, it looks okay on some of your sigs, but it's sort of old. :/