Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[gamerdude247]

yeah it didn't turn out very well, and here's a new one...it was simple, but i like it

 

[Brawny]

Argh, nice C&C's.....

@ Gamerdude

#1, no border. it seems you lost a LOT of detail on the "flames". I'm guessing an overdone dodge/burn layer?

There's no depth or flow, the eye starts moving at the left side, then as it travels right, it just gets lost in the blahhh.

GJ blending the render though....almost too much....

 

[gamerdude247]

ok, thanks for the advice...i have a question though...

1. how do i add those lines like in monsteroids' sig?

and was that for the samus or goblin one?

 

[Monsteroids]

MORE C&C on my siggy people!!!

 

[gamerdude247]

how do you add the lines like in monster's sig? (someone answer who knows how to do it in PS7)

 

[Byuakuya]

At Brawny: Your first Sig, the Mortal Kombat one and the last Sig (your current) are my favourites. The Pop-Up Sig is very nicely done, although the render could be blended-in a bit more.

 

[gamerdude247]

does anyone know how 2 put the lines in? (like in monsteroids sig)

and C&C on my new sig

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Don't like it. Video isn't needed and the Render, Well I can't tell who/what it is lol

Also Monster's Lines is probably a Stock image or a Render with Overlay effect [Orange Background making the lines Orange]

I suppose

I need C&C from my Lastest

[/QUOTE]

 

[gamerdude247]

don't really like it much, too much shattered blue glass, i don't think you added lightning effects, text is better on the first of the two, you did add a border (what i need to start doing), the render is pretty good...not enough effects...ohh and the render i used was "big daddy" from the game "bioshock"

6/10

 

[Byuakuya]

Don't like it. Video isn't needed and the Render, Well I can't tell who/what it is lol

Also Monster's Lines is probably a Stock image or a Render with Overlay effect [Orange Background making the lines Orange]

I suppose

I need C&C from my Lastest

You have used too many C4Ds within a small space Wii_Smurf. And I think you can also add more lighting and blend-in the render a bit more.

Gamerdude247: Its not your best. The render is hard to figure out and the BG is plain.

 

[gamerdude247]

...that's why i give the video

 

[Monsteroids]

Theres no stocks in my sig. I used my brushes on it colapsed all of the layers except spidey whos on top. The I went to Filters->Distorts->Video Selected 3x3 small and checked the "rotated" box and voilla!

Gamerdude I am going to come out in complete honesty: The video kills it for me...
Same with your current one. It looked great without the video.
Smurf: Those C4Ds are painfully visible.

Somethin' I've been working on:

 

[gamerdude247]

in photoshop you can't go filter>distort>video...video isn't there

 

[Monsteroids]

Well then do what Smurf said. That may work.

 

[demonflair]

Incorrect.

Also I joined PR for real critique on sigs, and I give honest C&C to others.

Yeah, Mike's right. You must be unaware of what a great/legend sig is Ryan.. I've seen some incredible sigs with no use of C4Ds, they're incredible probably because they don't have C4Ds too. :wink:

And same here, joined PR because of real C&C and for some other reasons.
You people need to learn allot really, we all need.

Oh and Ryan, to give you an example of a great sig without a C4D, a sig with a great concept.