Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[Byuakuya]

Those are some classic pieces Shiftfallout. I can't wait for the next one. :lol:

 

[demonflair]

Those are some classic pieces Shiftfallout. I can't wait for the next one. :lol:

You made another sig and avy... I don't like them tbh :sick: :scared:
Sorry buddy, not your best works imo.

 

[Byuakuya]

You made another sig and avy... I don't like them tbh :sick: :scared:
Sorry buddy, not your best works imo.

Thanks for the feedback Ricardo, thats exactly what I thought. But I had to change it to freshen things up. I will start working on a better one next. Thanks for your comments.
Remember: The more brutal the critic, the better the improvement (hopefully). :lol:

 

[demonflair]

Thanks for the feedback Ricardo, thats exactly what I thought. But I had to change it to freshen things up. I will start working on a better one next. Thanks for your comments.
Remember: The more brutal the critic, the better the improvement (hopefully). :lol:

I hope that's not your new style :scared:

Anyway I made this sig for High Definition, he asked me for a video animation on it:

 

[Byuakuya]

I hope that's not your new style :scared:

Anyway I made this sig for High Definition, he asked me for a video animation on it:

No, its not my new style. :lol:
Yeah, the video Sig looks good, but I think the video section should be moved up a little. It shouldn't touch the border area.

 

[demonflair]

No, its not my new style. :lol:
Yeah, the video Sig looks good, but I think the video section should be moved up a little. It shouldn't touch the border area.

I wasn't sure about it's position... it was hard to decide. Meh... I'm going to leave it like that...

 

[Gymdawg]

I definitely don't like the video placement. It looks like it's just stuck there; probably because it's just stuck there. You need to move it to a better spot and blend it in with the actual banner.

 

[demonflair]

I definitely don't like the video placement. It looks like it's just stuck there; probably because it's just stuck there. You need to move it to a better spot and blend it in with the actual banner.

Exactly what I thought. Thanks for the comment

Here's a sig I made for Mr Resi:

C&C please

 

[Star Striker]

Heres a few I made last night:

 

[ssbb_lover]

Exactly what I thought. Thanks for the comment

Here's a sig I made for Mr Resi:

C&C please

Start Striker, so you ARE ToadIsDoingMushrooms? I had a feeling...

Anyways, nice sig Demon. This one's right on up there...i'd say second only to your current. Did better with the pen tool though. The double render's a bit odd, but without it I suppose it'd be quite empty. GJ overall. 8/10

Oh, and star, nice sigs...but the only good one really is the 1st one. The others get a 6/10 in my book. :/ Last one get's an 8/10 just because it's the Arctic Monkeys. -_-

 

[Star Striker]

Yup! I have revealed my true identity! :lol:

 

[Byuakuya]

Exactly what I thought. Thanks for the comment

Here's a sig I made for Mr Resi:

C&C please

That looks very nice. I have seen better Sigs from you, but this one still looks good.

 

[ssbb_lover]

Pras, good try with the small canvas. Keep working at it. But you've kind of proved your weakness...let me explain.

Do you see why your sig is quite...well, tbh, droll? It's because with those long sigs of yours, you became accustomed to making the background the highlight of the sig. Now with such a smaller canvas, you can't make as much of the background, can you? You have to focus on the effects of the render, making it the pinnacle of your sig, you have to have a strong theme.

(^^ too over dramatic?)

Good render though, I really like it. :]

 

[Byuakuya]

Pras, good try with the small canvas. Keep working at it. But you've kind of proved your weakness...let me explain.

Do you see why your sig is quite...well, tbh, droll? It's because with those long sigs of yours, you became accustomed to making the background the highlight of the sig. Now with such a smaller canvas, you can't make as much of the background, can you? You have to focus on the effects of the render, making it the pinnacle of your sig, you have to have a strong theme.

(^^ too over dramatic?)

Good render though, I really like it. :]

Yeah, I had a real hard time because I couldn't work on the BG that much. You can tell that I have been practicing on this one. :lol:
I will (hopefully) get better at it with time. Thanks for the feedback.
By the way, any ideas on what else I can do with future Sigs to make them stand out on a smaller canvas?

 

[demonflair]

Pras, good try with the small canvas. Keep working at it. But you've kind of proved your weakness...let me explain.

Do you see why your sig is quite...well, tbh, droll? It's because with those long sigs of yours, you became accustomed to making the background the highlight of the sig. Now with such a smaller canvas, you can't make as much of the background, can you? You have to focus on the effects of the render, making it the pinnacle of your sig, you have to have a strong theme.

(^^ too over dramatic?)

Good render though, I really like it. :]

He did tryed to focus on the render, a little bit, by adding that light effect. Well it's a start
Like Tyler said:

You became accustomed to making the background the highlight of the sig. Now with such a smaller canvas, you can't make as much of the background.

Exactly what I'm thinking

EDIT*

By the way, any ideas on what else I can do with future Sigs to make them stand out on a smaller canvas?

Add light effects, create a focal point, try to change the colors with Photofilters, that will give a good effect on the lights too.