Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[King Wiired]

Large amount of experimentation with this sig (most you can't see where I've gone over it and such) but you may be able to notice some of it. I'm not happy with it but I want some crique on how it could be improved, 'cause I've had a 'writers block' of sig making :sick: it's annoying me alot, and thought asking for ideas could boost my motivation and ideas.
Well here it is:

Harsh critique is better
Note : I just quickly bunged in some text, and didn't bother with a border yet. To avoid views on that thanks.

 

[Close]

Bad render. And bad lightning/spotlight effect.

 

[King Wiired]

Bad render. And bad lightning/spotlight effect.

Thanks might have some time off from sig making, I really can't think.. :sick:

 

[demonflair]

Large amount of experimentation with this sig (most you can't see where I've gone over it and such) but you may be able to notice some of it. I'm not happy with it but I want some crique on how it could be improved, 'cause I've had a 'writers block' of sig making :sick: it's annoying me alot, and thought asking for ideas could boost my motivation and ideas.
Well here it is:

Harsh critique is better
Note : I just quickly bunged in some text, and didn't bother with a border yet. To avoid views on that thanks.

The only thing good about it, it's the text. As to the rest of the sig I think that you can do way better than that.

 

[ssbb_lover]

Mike, one of your worst sigs in a long while tbh. :/

Like Demon said, the text is good though.

 

[King Wiired]

Lol thanks lads (not being sarcastic). I was really struggling with ideas for like the first time ever, so just decided to put anything together, and that's what I came up with. A weeks break from making anything seems like a good idea to me

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Sort it Wiired lol, J/K I don't like it though it's better than anything I could do

 

[ssbb_lover]

Lol thanks lads (not being sarcastic). I was really struggling with ideas for like the first time ever, so just decided to put anything together, and that's what I came up with. A weeks break from making anything seems like a good idea to me

Not sure what you mean by sig break down though...I love your 2nd to latest one, which is your current.

 

[Gymdawg]

Honestl, that sig is terrible. I mean, it's got a lot of neat stuff in it, but it's all thrown together horribly. That spotlight it creates a nasty drop off to black at the sides. There's a white line around the render. It's just really bad.

Sorry mate, but find somewhere to bury that and move on.
:sick:

 

[Gymdawg]

Whoo, double posting like a nub.

Just in case anyone was wondering, here's where my afternoon went.
(I find I work a lot harder when my girlfriend is 650 miles away...)

 

[ssbb_lover]

Whoo, double posting like a nub.

Just in case anyone was wondering, here's where my afternoon went.
(I find I work a lot harder when my girlfriend is 650 miles away...)

Did you use a stock?

 

[Gymdawg]

Yep, do you like it?

 

[ssbb_lover]

Yep, do you like it?

It's nice. I like it. By "nice" i'm comparing it to your standards. If I made that it'd be "FTW GAWD THAT'S AWESOMEEEE". But you know, we're comparing it with your abilities.

I like it better than the pop-out one with this render (you know, not the exact render, but the same...skeleton thing). I really like the hailing red fire sparks coming from the volcano (?). Long answer short: yes, I like it.

On a side note, almost done with SOTW #10...totally different style for me.

 

[ssbb_lover]

Gym did it. :scared:

Like I said...very different for me. It's busy...but I think I like it. I learned how to use the pen tool better...and I know it doesn't have a border, but i'm not sure what to do it with it.

 

[demonflair]

On a side note, almost done with SOTW #10...totally different style for me.

Speaking of different styles, here's my possible entry in SOTW 10:

In this sig I used the pen tool, dunno if it's okay... made lightings, and used C4D renders. BTW the render is Animal Crossing.

@ Gym, you did a wonderful job on that sig. It's really well made. But I can't read the text, I only know there's an Angel in it.