Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #676
demonflair said:
New sig made for Bob:

bobdingleys-sig.gif


UPDATE:

bobdingleys-sig-2.gif
The render totally clashes with the bg IMO. The bg is too busy, I can't really find a place in it where a part stands out significantly more than another part. All that aside, the 2nd is better. :)
 
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #678
Brawny said:
Lol, little harsh today?

he does have some true points. He is just brutally honest.

from now on..use TBBH
To be brutally honest...I think I will use that now. :]

Not harsh, I just try to give the best criticism I can give so that the sig maker can improve on what I pointed out as much as possible. Of course he might like busy bg's (which I think he does, every bg he's ever made is practically busy :lol: ), and I criticized that, but he doesn't have to take that advice.

And at least I added a smiley at the end of the post, that makes everything better. :)
 
Okay, I don't do the best work at midnight. But here goes:

hammer2.png


and I added a border. yes, I know it is the most difficult thing ever.

norender4dfferent-1.png
 
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #681
All you English folk are on right now. :/
Brawny said:
Okay, I don't do the best work at midnight. But here goes:

hammer2.png


and I added a border. yes, I know it is the most difficult thing ever.

norender4dfferent-1.png
Your borders are too thick IMO. They can look good sometimes, but try making them a bit thinner?
 
He he, says the guy with an 8 pixel border on current

And I forgot the to save the xcf of the project hammer one. You'll just have to wait till next week I guess.
 
I'm gonna have a crack at another sig now, might post it later.

Done a bloodrayne one now time for a FPS one. . .
 
@Brawny: I prefer your old signature (the blue one with no picture). That was a good peice of yours. This one seems dark and glum to me.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top