Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[Foxy]

C&C
Spent a little bit following a tut...hate the out come​

 

[gidget]

burrrrr those look icy cold, cappin! :yesnod: looks frosty...

no comment on mine earlier... here's an update with filters.
[deleted]

 

[Gikoku Harakami]

That piece seems to have an under-water feeling. Nicely done Gikoku.

Thanks, Byu. I was trying to go for more of a burning Sun kind of feel, but with all those dots floating away from the light source, it does look like it's underwater. :lol:.

The light source is too much white for me, it'd probably look smexy if you have a photo filter on cooling filter but you have gimp. :sick:

Actually, I use Photoshop CS3.. not GIMP (Don't remember saying I ever did.. hmm).

I tried a cooling filter while I was making it, the results didn't look very good in my opinion. So I stuck with a Sepia filter, to keep the warm feeling it has. However, now that I think about, I have to agree... that light source is rather a bit too bright. Thanks for the feedback, Close.

woah, gikoku uses gimp?i thougt he uses PS o.o

:lol: Nah, I use Photoshop. I imagine I'd have to be something pretty crazy to be able whip something like that up in GIMP.

this looks so great, gikoku ... are the swirls smudges?

Thanks, idjut . They were smudges at first, but then I liquefied them for a more flame-ish look.

Ok guys, here is my latest:

Any and all comments and critiques are welcome.

I like this one, Byu. Once again, the background smudging is very well done. The text looks fine to me, maybe slightly lower the opacity. I'm not really sure about those two large circles underneath the text though, I mean the other circles and +'s look fine, but the way you did those two makes them distract from the others. Overall, nicely done my friend. :yesnod:

no comment on mine earlier... here's an update with filters.

Looks pretty good, but it's too dark. Try adding some light to it, to brighten it up a bit. Also looks a little bit naked without some text, i think a good spot would be diagonally above her left arm (be sure to adjust the opacity of it afterwards).

 

[Close]

@Mike, thanks so much for the c/c, it will truly help me, and I will begin a new style !m XD

@Gikoku- Oh, my bad, anyway, I'm glad atleast you tried it

 

[Foxy]

Yet more...

C&C


VV--For Tyly--VV

Spoiler

 

[gidget]

Looks pretty good, but it's too dark. Try adding some light to it, to brighten it up a bit. Also looks a little bit naked without some text, i think a good spot would be diagonally above her left arm (be sure to adjust the opacity of it afterwards).

ok v2 is overwritten... here's v3

i started over, cut her back out with AA & feathering... this prevented the need for all the blurring... :yesnod:
text will come later when i have a sn to add :yesnod:

[deleted]

C&C
​

 

[iRAWR]

the jam loves tyler thingy...i find it a bit plain, maybe put a light source in the bottom left part? and maybe instead of a hard bursh, use a soft bursh? (well, if gimp has any)

 

[Close]

the jam loves tyler thingy...i find it a bit plain, maybe put a light source in the bottom left part? and maybe instead of a hard bursh, use a soft bursh? (well, if gimp has any)

Dude it's a black bg, blue text, and a WinterBreeze brush. :sick:

 

[iRAWR]

lol, true that.

 

[Close]

Yeah, anybody wanna comment on this ?

 

[gidget]

close, can you incorporate some red behind the word CHAT... kinda give the wiichat theme... maybe white behind the Wii ?

i just did another change on my samus... can you C&C?

v4 -- sn text to be added when claimed.

 

[Foxy]

the jam loves tyler thingy...i find it a bit plain, maybe put a light source in the bottom left part? and maybe instead of a hard bursh, use a soft bursh? (well, if gimp has any)

Why comment on the thing that didn't need commenting on:lol:

 

[iRAWR]

Yeah, anybody wanna comment on this ?

a bit too..PR like? :wtf:

c/c

ehh..cant see white border =/

 

[Close]

a bit too..PR like? :wtf:

c/c

ehh..cant see white border =/

Bad colors because of blue. Nice white brush (?) The splatter brushings look bad.


Maybe you think it looks like PR's badge because of the background is similar ? Idk.

 

[iRAWR]

well, i just think the whole colour and the scanlines in the back are bit too to "PR themed", well since this is a wii forum..make it wii themed? :scared: