Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

Popert said:
Well, being positive, positive, positive doesn't really help anyone's skills. ;)
Click to expand...

Yeah I obviously know that, that's why I'm not asking for that.

c/c - COMMENTS and criticisms

If Close is just gonna critisize every time (and it's not even constructive criticism), then that won't help a sig maker's morale.

So bascially, all Close leaves for everything is worthless criticisms. He's not helping anyone out.

But if that's how he does it, then fine. I'll do the same for him. And since that last sig he posted was absolutely horrendous, here's my c&c for it : It sucks.

Hope that helps you next time you make a sig Close!:D
 
Lol, gettin' a little rough eh? Well I have to agree with ssbb. Both is the best.

___________________________
Hey can any of you help me find a good render/stock with a girl/guy kneeling on the ground on his/her knees staring into the sky? Please? I am trying out something new...
 
Popert said:
Lol, gettin' a little rough eh? Well I have to agree with ssbb. Both is the best.

___________________________
Hey can any of you help me find a good render/stock with a girl/guy kneeling on the ground on his/her knees staring into the sky? Please? I am trying out something new...
Click to expand...

Yes, I WANT both. When I comment on sigs, I will start off with the negatives (if there are any), and then go with the positives, and end it with my overall thoughts of the sig.
 
Sneaux125 said:
Yeah I obviously know that, that's why I'm not asking for that.

c/c - COMMENTS and criticisms

If Close is just gonna critisize every time (and it's not even constructive criticism), then that won't help a sig maker's morale.

So bascially, all Close leaves for everything is worthless criticisms. He's not helping anyone out.

But if that's how he does it, then fine. I'll do the same for him. And since that last sig he posted was absolutely horrendous, here's my c&c for it : It sucks.

Hope that helps you next time you make a sig Close!:D
Click to expand...

LMAO ! All I said it had a bit too much apply images and then you spaz out and cry saying everything I post is negative. :lol:

Oh yeah, I just say yeah, no flaws in your sig at all Sneaux, absolutely perfect. It wouldnt help.

My sig was absolutely horrendous ? Yeah, your sigs are awesome.....

Worthless criticisms ? Yeah look at the sig I 'criticized' and your current. There is definitely BARELY any apply images. And on top of that I put In my opinion !

I shouldnt even type this 'long' of a post since your a newb. Yeah, Less than 100 posts and joined what ? Last month ? But I typed this because I'm not gonna take smack from insignificant member such as you. But if Dark Prinny, i0n, SSBBLover, Ricky, (Jill) :(, Capt. Mccloud, Steph, Syntax, Brawny, etc... any vet. Because they have my respect greatly. Perhaps later you will have my respect, when you actually have made more than 2 threads -.-
 
Close said:
LMAO ! All I said it had a bit too much apply images and then you spaz out and cry saying everything I post is negative. :lol:

Oh yeah, I just say yeah, no flaws in your sig at all Sneaux, absolutely perfect. It wouldnt help.

My sig was absolutely horrendous ? Yeah, your sigs are awesome.....

Worthless criticisms ? Yeah look at the sig I 'criticized' and your current. There is definitely BARELY any apply images. And on top of that I put In my opinion !

I shouldnt even type this 'long' of a post since your a newb. Yeah, Less than 100 posts and joined what ? Last month ? But I typed this because I'm not gonna take smack from insignificant member such as you. But if Dark Prinny, i0n, SSBBLover, Ricky, (Jill) :(, Capt. Mccloud, Steph, Syntax, Brawny, etc... any vet. Because they have my respect greatly. Perhaps later you will have my respect, when you actually have made more than 2 threads -.-
Click to expand...

1. Nearly everything you post IS negative
2. I'm not looking for that
3. Yes, that sig, and your current aren't all that great. I mean I've seen potential in your tutorials, but the sigs I've actually seen made by you aren't very good. Maybe you should follow your own tutorials more often so you can actually make a good sig.
4.I have nothing. You made no sense. First you say I have too many apply images, and then you say I barely have any. And idk what my current has to do with this. And I understand you added your opinion, but on this thread we're also supposed to help other sig makers. You were no help at all.
5. So you're saying I need to make threads to be significant? I didn't know forums were all about making threads. I'm pretty sure posting in them is just as significant. And yeah, I'm a new member, but so waht, I'm just the same as anyone else, just with less posts. At least I'm active:rolleyes:
 
Sneaux125 said:
4.I have nothing. You made no sense. First you say I have too many apply images, and then you say I barely have any. And idk what my current has to do with this. And I understand you added your opinion, but on this thread we're also supposed to help other sig makers. You were no help at all.
Click to expand...

There really isnt anything to reply but:

It is called ' Sarcasm '. I use it very often in day to day life, it makes a lot of my friends laugh. Look it up. :)

I really do appreciate that you are active. :)
 
Close said:
There really isnt anything to reply but:

It is called ' Sarcasm '. I use it very often in day to day life, it makes a lot of my friends laugh. Look it up. :)

I really do appreciate that you are active. :)
Click to expand...

Excuse me for not noticing sarcasm through text on the Internet. Such a silly mistake of mine. I must have down syndrome.
 
Sneaux125 said:
Excuse me for not noticing sarcasm through text on the Internet. Such a silly mistake of mine. I must have down syndrome.
Click to expand...

Yeah, you probably do.


Lmao, j/k :ciappa:
 
Sneaux125 said:
Newest -

sig208.png


c/c
Click to expand...
I personally like the outcome. It may be a little busy in the background, but it all adds to the chaotic atmosphere. Nicely done.
 
Sneaux125 said:
Well if I do, I'm at least the smartest kid with down syndrome:wtf:
Click to expand...

Tru dat. I like the sig overall (positive). It had good depth as well as great flow. BUT it is a little busy BECAUSE of that many apply images. Maybe take away the Circle Vector brushes, and add a little more width (which you can't do on this sig of course, but maybe your next one) so it had more bg to calm down the sig a bit which adds some depth.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

King Wiired
*The Photoshop Help Thread*
2 3
Replies
36
Views
5K
Mario Famous
Mario Famous
ssbb_lover
  • Sticky
Humongous Compiling of All Your GFX Needs (HCAYGFXN)
2 3
Replies
32
Views
15K
Byuakuya
Byuakuya

Latest posts

Back
Top