Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[ssbb_lover]

Sneaux, I like how you reworked the LP stock, I think it looks great.


Pras, I like it, but next time try putting some crazy effects and whatnot. Yes?

 

[Popert]

Sneaux I love the LP one...

And Byu, very nice. I would just love some effects in there...

CnC on current?
Not so good I know. I did it in about 5-10 minutes...

 

[ssbb_lover]

• Canvas size is too large IMO
• TRY NEW STYLES OF TEXT AND WAYS OF INCORPORATING IT
• Definitely need more effects for such a gray/bland sig (work more with that electric blue color)
• I do like the way you made his hands in color, clever
• Needs better depth
• Darken the bottom right side of the sig and you'll have a better looking light source

 

[Close]

• Canvas size is too large IMO
• TRY NEW STYLES OF TEXT AND WAYS OF INCORPORATING IT
• Definitely need more effects for such a gray/bland sig (work more with that electric blue color)
• I do like the way you made his hands in color, clever
• Needs better depth
• Darken the bottom right side of the sig and you'll have a better looking light source

I agree. But it is great originality though XD

 

[ssbb_lover]

I agree. Just making the canvas size smaller (in width, not height) would make it awesome.

 

[Popert]

Well, before I read your tips I started and finished this one.
So here it is:
V1

V2

 

[Close]

Do you make that circle by eliptical marquee tool, stroke, and outer glow ? Or with apply image ?

 

[Popert]

I'll make a tut on it soon!

 

[Sneaux125]

I'll make a tut on it soon!

I'll be looking forward to that. I like the idea. It's very unique and original.

 

[Byuakuya]

Sneaux, I like how you reworked the LP stock, I think it looks great.


Pras, I like it, but next time try putting some crazy effects and whatnot. Yes?

Sneaux I love the LP one...

And Byu, very nice. I would just love some effects in there...

CnC on current?
Not so good I know. I did it in about 5-10 minutes...

I was actually going for a simple Sig, since some of my earlier pieces were over-loaded with effects to some extent. But I guess you guys prefer to see some over-the-top effects in there. :lol:

 

[Popert]

Anyone suggest a good size for a tut?

CnC on recent?

 

[M@gicM@rk]

The lines on the right, omit them or change the color and make them blend better.
The red circle is also a bit distracting (unless that was the intended focal point), I'd suggest changing the color to make it blend.

The background is a bit bland, lacks depth...
Text is decent.

Overall, work on colors and blending. :yesnod:
(And I'm one to talk. ¬_¬)



I decided to whip something up for PR's NSotW (Freestyle + the word "Philosophy" in there), but it didn't come out as I hoped...

Didn't really like the colors, so made a b/w

 

[Sneaux125]

My newest -

c/c

Mark : The two lines on both sides of the focal are very MS Paintish looking. Also, the focal colors don't really match the rest of the sig. I really like the B/W one though; it shows that it has a lot of potential.

 

[Popert]

M@gic, the render looks over-sharpened to me. And Sneaux, its good, but not your best.

 

[iRAWR]

The lines on the right, omit them or change the color and make them blend better.
The red circle is also a bit distracting (unless that was the intended focal point), I'd suggest changing the color to make it blend.

The background is a bit bland, lacks depth...
Text is decent.

Overall, work on colors and blending. :yesnod:
(And I'm one to talk. ¬_¬)



I decided to whip something up for PR's NSotW (Freestyle + the word "Philosophy" in there), but it didn't come out as I hoped...

Didn't really like the colors, so made a b/w

too sharpened.....