Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[demonflair]

SSBB_lover, i think you overdid the lighting but overall its good

Yeah that's why the black gradient would look nice if it was in soft light.

 

[Almo]

my two latest, CC please, i know its empty in the middle, was room for a vid.

 

[Star Striker]

Very nice work Star Striker. Some of your best yet in my opinion. Also great use of the pen tool. Out of those five signatures I would have to say numbers 1, 3 and 4 would have to be my favourite. Keep up the good work there Star.

I didn't use the pen tool because I don't now how.

I used a hard round 3px brush and outlined one side of the render. I then used the Wave distort filter to make it sort of wavy (obviously) and deleted parts to give the sig some depth.

Also to add depth I used the burn tool on the edges and played with bluring and sharpening.

 

[Syntax]

Either way nice work on all of the signatures...

Swear it looked like the pen tool..

Question: Regarding SOTW 15 which of these signatures looks better?

 

[demonflair]

My latest:

@Syntax, I don't know, I just can't decide which one is better..

 

[Monsteroids]

Meh... dabbled about and made a new avy.

 

[tarheelsuperman]

My nature entry...

...Until I change my mind. Comments?

 

[Byuakuya]

Either way nice work on all of the signatures...

Swear it looked like the pen tool..

Question: Regarding SOTW 15 which of these signatures looks better?

I personally like the second one.
At Ricardo and Tarheel: Both Sigs are very nice.

 

[ssbb_lover]

I like both of the sigs except for the text. >.> In Ricky's, it looks like it's totally just thrown on there. On Tarheel's, you always use that same font. Sometimes it doesn't match the sig, IMO, this is one of those times.

Ricky: 9/10

Tarheel: 8/10

 

[demonflair]

I like both of the sigs except for the text. >.> In Ricky's, it looks like it's totally just thrown on there. On Tarheel's, you always use that same font. Sometimes it doesn't match the sig, IMO, this is one of those times.

Ricky: 9/10


Tarheel: 8/10

Good thanks

Made for a Sotw in Planetrenders:

With the theme being Death.

 

[Star Striker]

I'll not be making sigs for quite a while.

This Gangs of Arabia is awesome!

:lol:

 

[Popert]

Can you guys please comment on this sig?

 

[ssbb_lover]

Can you guys please comment on this sig?

Stop using that render, dammit. -_-

Nah, really. It's better than your other attempts (definitely), bg is still very simple, but it at least it's better background. I like those random red lines (even though they blend a little too much colorwise)...is that pen tool, something with the "wave" filter applied to it? Moving on, text is much better, the render unfortunately looks low quality...6/10 Large step up from you, GJ buddy.

 

[Close]

Can you guys please comment on this sig?

Horrible background, it has no depth in the bg, or the sig at all.

Alright border, render is not blended.

It appears that the light source is at the bottom, while the text has the light source at the top.........

Barely any flow. I do like those random lines at the bottom left.

4.5/10

 

[ssbb_lover]

Barely any flow. I do like those random lines at the bottom left.

Agreed, but I think the lines would look much better where the render is placed.