Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[ssbb_lover]

Hmm...interesting reaction. Thanks a lot guys. Waiting for Gym/Wiired to destroy me with their critique. xD

though if we get any more comps we may as well quit our day jobs since were gonna need the extra time

LMFAO, that's the funniest thing i've read all day.

 

[tarheelsuperman]

I like your little S & L blocks, something about the floor just looks off to me though...It may be the angle of the floor boards in comparison to the shelf. I think they need to be at the same angle. Also maybe put some kind of color in to the floor and walls. Just a few thoughts.

As for IOTW please no...there is quite enough design work to do with the EOTW and SOTW not to mention the constant stream of sig requests. I barely ever play my Wii, DS, or watch TV anymore after my kids are in bed. I am addicted to photoshop now though...THANKS FOR THAT GUYS!!!

 

[Byuakuya]

Something i've been working on...I don't know what to call it. I just felt like doing it...it's more of a picture than a sig (even though the dimensions are for a sig PPP). Small animation, everything was custom made except for the Prime "sprite" (I thought it looked like a toy, which gave me the inspiration. I was going to do a lot more with it, but i'd need MUCH larger height dimensions). Just for reference, I looked at no tutorials and no sigs gave me the idea, so I won't say it's original, but this has to be my 1st sig that was inspired from another tut/sig....also tried to throw in a bit of perspective. Feedback would be great.

IMO, it's crappy. No actual "style" was used. I was basically just creating an image..bahh, I dunno. I just felt like making it.

If it had text, then it would be a great Sig entry for SOTW 11. :lol:
Just kidding. It looks simple but colourful.

 

[demonflair]

If it had text, then it would be a great Sig entry for SOTW 11. :lol:
Just kidding. It looks simple but colourful.

Ermm... cough* text... in the... TVs *cough

I am addicted to photoshop now though...THANKS FOR THAT GUYS!!!

Same here
I almost don't play in my Wii or watch TV at all... when I'm in home, it's only Photoshop with me

 

[Star Striker]

Some of my creations from yesterday.

Love this:

As you can see, some are better than others. IMO the Killzone one is crap.

 

[Byuakuya]

Ermm... cough* text... in the... TVs *cough

I didn't notice that at first, so thanks for pointing it out.

At Star Striker: I think that the second Sig and the Spawn one look great.

 

[demonflair]

Some of my creations from yesterday.

Love this:

As you can see, some are better than others. IMO the Killzone one is crap.

Star I have a suggestion for you. Try to only work with one and only one sig, then try to improve your skills in that sig. Don't make many sigs at the same time or else you wont improve that much imo...

As for those sigs, the second is very cool, although the text looks like a rip from Ben's texts :lol: jk

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Yeah, Thief
Lol. Nah I like those signatures tbh. I prefer to make laods of signatures rather than stick with one lol. Good Work :thumbsup:

 

[Star Striker]

I put a lot of time into each signature and there's only so much you can do to each one so I start a new one when the one I'm working on is finished.

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Yeah
Anyways:
I've finished 3 signatures recently. C&C Please

Mario Signature Using This Tutorial

Cloud Signature I made

Same Cloud Signature with help from DemonFlair

 

[Star Striker]

Personally, I only like the 2nd........

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Personally, I only like the 2nd........

Thats the one I made lol.
I like DemonFlairs edit but I feel too much Gradient was used. It's still good how he combined them though. As for the Mario one. Maybe too plain? I mean too much white background.

Thanks for the feedback anyways Striker

 

[Star Striker]

Thats the one I made lol.
I like DemonFlairs edit but I feel too much Gradient was used. It's still good how he combined them though. As for the Mario one. Maybe too plain? I mean too much white background.

Thanks for the feedback anyways Striker

You've summed up the problems perfectly! Also, too much light has been used in the 3rd IMO.

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Lol
I updated the 2nd one with a Border, I can't believe I forgot that

 

[Byuakuya]

Yeah
Anyways:
I've finished 3 signatures recently. C&C Please

Mario Signature Using This Tutorial

Cloud Signature I made

Same Cloud Signature with help from DemonFlair

The second one looks the best. Gives it a really dark feeling. Very nice.