Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[ssbb_lover]

Wow I hate that one, and there are so many verys in opinions on the internet it is crazy :lol: I think this is my best sig ever, the people on nsl ranked it intermediate, people on this other forum I'm on said they were drooling and bowing, whilst here you say a crappy sig is my best ever... I'm so confused :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

Then again, take into consideration i've just been working with PS for over a month...lol. I'm not quite up to NSL standards if you catch my drift...

Sorry, just don't see anything amazing about it which would make me drool. :/ I'm hard to please.

 

[demonflair]

wow I wait until now to throw out a good Nintendo sig

Love it
It's amazing, would give a great wallpaper if it was big. I love the bg colors, the lights, the position of the toad, everything matches greatly

 

[King Wiired]

wow I wait until now to throw out a good Nintendo sig

I don't really like any of 'em all that much tbh buddy.. it looks like 2 sigs blended together. Not too fond of Toad being on the side, or having the bit of brush on his face and mushroom thing. The left side looks a tad to sharp, I don't think the light source is in the right place, and I don't think the render suits the sig If you made the two halves into once seperate sigs with different renders, I'd probably prefer it, but namely the render is what lets you down here. Though I do like the brushing towards to bottom of Toad, and the background effects on the right, just isn't my kinda sig tbh.

 

[Wii_Smurf]

This could be my entry for the SOTW this week.

Tell me what you think

I need to make the background transparent yet [Any idea on how to do that]

 

[demonflair]

This could be my entry for the SOTW this week.

Tell me what you think

I need to make the background transparent yet [Any idea on how to do that]

Delete the background.


Ok here's two sigs I made:

Both are meant for this SOTW 11.

Here's the old sig:

And here's the new sig:

Which sig shall I enter with??

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Whats the Resi Evil one for? Maybe the developer who made it
I'd say the resi evil one

[I updated my signatures above]

 

[gamerdude247]

the second one demonflair

 

[Spaggy]

I'd vote for the first one, that's for sure. It catches me eye.

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Ok
Added the Brand name for the SOTW Entry
What ya think?

 

[Star Striker]

Here are IMO my best signatures to date:

Slight variation on above:

 

[gamerdude247]

nice

 

[Star Striker]

Cheers. I've made a tutorial that I will upload soon. It's a huuuuge file.

 

[Wii_Smurf]

Ok, Cheers

 

[Star Striker]

Tut now in it's own thread in the design lounge. Feedback appreciated!

 

[demonflair]

Here are IMO my best signatures to date:

Slight variation on above:

Good, you're definitely improving. The fist PoP is your best sig so far imo
Keep up the good work.

And again this is confusing me...

Which one is the best sig??