1v1 brawl league

[Bio]

After reading some posts, the only good idea mentioned so far is low tier bonus. I would say an extra 10 points is good enough. Everything else should be as I originally suggested unless there are some other good ideas. As always, post your thoughts.

As for the "no conversing" thing: While it's unrealistic to think we are only gonna talk about matches, don't be the idiot who keeps contributing to an unrelated conversation that has been going for several posts, as it just derails the whole thread. If you are making more of an effort to continue some long conversation about something else over keeping the thread on-topic...then don't post. If you HAVE to keep it going, take it to PM.

This isn't rocket science, people.

 

[Pichu2k7]

Atleast I know not to post off-topic if its gonna made the whole thread off topic now...it feels good to be on brawl again stuff so if any wants to brawl try for about 9PM GMT since I have school tomorrow but it's my last day

 

[Lastwords?]

After reading some posts, the only good idea mentioned so far is low tier bonus. I would say an extra 10 points is good enough. Everything else should be as I originally suggested unless there are some other good ideas. As always, post your thoughts.

As for the "no conversing" thing: While it's unrealistic to think we are only gonna talk about matches, don't be the idiot who keeps contributing to an unrelated conversation that has been going for several posts, as it just derails the whole thread. If you are making more of an effort to continue some long conversation about something else over keeping the thread on-topic...then don't post. If you HAVE to keep it going, take it to PM.

This isn't rocket science, people.

Bio!? Are you kiding me?
10 pts? double your score for using a low tier?? thats rediculus. When I made the idea of adding points for lower tier, I ment minor, as in:
-Mid-tier +1 to final score (Instead of earning 10pts, they get 11)
-Low tier +2 to final score (12)

Its not fair (pichu im using you as an example) if pichu has his main & sub main in low tier and always gets double points. Meaning me & ck who use high tier get half that. MEANING pichu could easily become champion of the league point wise with no effort at all. Lets say ZeroSuitowner came back (The league noob) And pichu played him and beat him 5 times... Pichu would get +100 points for beating a noob with his main
And thus if he did that agian hed become champion. That is in no way fair at all.

 

[real-o]

First, I have to agree with Lastwords, 10pts extra for using low tier is way too much.

I've read through all of the Melee bonuses and picked out the ones I think would work okay, all of them would be worth no more than 2 points each. I'm sure not everyone will agree but here they are:

Positives

Smash-less
- Used no Smash Attacks.
150% Damage
- Self-explanitory, will only be counted once per match (not per stock)
250% Damage
- Self-explanitory, will only be counted once per match (not per stock)
350% Damage
- Self-explanitory, will only be counted once per match (not per stock)
Shield Buster
- Broke enemy's shield.
Edge Hog
- Hung from edge to prevent opponent from doing the same. (Maybe this one should be negative? Discuss.)
No R 4 U (or No Shield)
- Did not use a shield.
Crowd Favorite
- Audience cheered for player.
Impervious
- Didn't suffer a single attack.
Wimpy KO
- KO'd a foe with a weak attack.
Timely KO
- KO'd a foe at the time limit.
Sacrificial KO
- The same attack KO'd both you and your enemy.
Avenger KO (or Revenge Killer)
- KO'd a foe right after foe KO'd you. (Within 5 seconds)


Negatives

Opportunist
- Didn't attack for a very long period of time. (needs a threshold)
Shattered Shield
- Shield was broken by enemy.
Shield Stupidity
- Broke own shield.
Stale Moves
- Persistently used the same attack. (needs a threshold)
Shameful Fall
- At less than 50%, got KO'd by a foe with over 100% damage.

And then we would make up some of our own, like the FALCON PAWNCH KO and Rest KO. I really don't see giving more than 1 or 2 points for any of these though. Opinions?

 

[Envek]

I like real-O's better.

 

[Lastwords?]

350% should be worth 3
And swazyland shouldbe added worth 3
And edgehoging is a skill so it should be positive or neutral 0-1pts

 

[GCommander]

I don't think that you should get points for edgehogging.

10 points is too much for using a low tier. Me using Samus.

 

[kingslayer]

I don't think there should be any bonus for using a low tier. If you chose to main a low tier, that was your choice. Anyone is free to play as Meta Knight if they want... there's nothing stopping them. Also, even though a character maybe lower tier than another character... they still may have an advantage over the higher tier character. Being higher tier only means that you have more better match ups... not that you completely shred every character lower on the tier list.

 

[Pichu2k7]

yeah the +10 bonus would definitly be unfair for people like CK, if it was just a +1 for winning against a top tier then sure go ahead with that plan and the melee bonus point idea would be awesome, so awesome that im coming on brawl right now XD

 

[Lastwords?]

so votes on little-no low tier bonus:
-Lastwords?
-king
-pichu
-gcommander?
-vote no

 

[Pichu2k7]

I'm more up for it to be fairer so im in for little only you have to beat a high tier with a low

 

[JonRyan]

wow can someone fill me in?

 

[Pichu2k7]

basically what I was thinkin of was if a low tier user beats a top tier user they get +1 bonus

 

[Lastwords?]

Hey hey now, I came up with idea over deductions.

 

[Pichu2k7]

Cool, lets hear then I can't wait to see how good they are!