Minto
You're kidding, right?
i use ONM and ignWii_Smurf said:
Quality of Reviews: Gamespot vs. IGN
- Thread starter NjD00
- Start date
XwiimasturX
Don't Mind Me. I'm Stupid
I chose IGN, cuz their reviews are much longer and much more detailed.
gamespot practically gives it a score and writes a paragraph.
that isnt enough to decide if a game is good or not.
gamespot practically gives it a score and writes a paragraph.
that isnt enough to decide if a game is good or not.
shift_andrew
The Dude
IGN reviews are vastly superior to Gamespot ones.
ThrillSeeker
The Italian
- Jan 2, 2007
- 36
- 1
- Wii Online Code
- 2128-5991-2659-7269
With scarface for example, I've played the game and it's sooo much fun. Not only that, the controls are soooooo well layed out for this type of game, so to see that gamespot actually said the controls were poor proved to me how terrible their editors are at playing and reviewing games. Gamespot = garbage
Ign is actually the website that comes closer to the average ranking you'll find on gamerankings.com and ign's reviews read much better.
Ign is actually the website that comes closer to the average ranking you'll find on gamerankings.com and ign's reviews read much better.
Sovieto
Banned
- Aug 6, 2006
- 6,569
- 91
OKAY
I AM SOVIETO
I AM RIGHT ON THIS
IGN is awesome for reviews, everywhere BUT the wii section, the Wii section is bias and they give high scores to almost everything where they arent deserved
For the Wii, go to GameSpot, 5.8 i say is an extremely accurate rating, its a very old port, tacked on motion controls, no updated graphics when they could be updated, gamespot is right, ign is being bias, with those cold hard facts i just stated there is no way you could give a game like that over 8.
you guys are all probably just saying IGN cause they scored it higher and you like the game, sure its a great game, but its a review compared to its other versions since it is a port, it has so much more potential, but on a console with hardly any good games, sure, its a game youd love
I AM SOVIETO
I AM RIGHT ON THIS
IGN is awesome for reviews, everywhere BUT the wii section, the Wii section is bias and they give high scores to almost everything where they arent deserved
For the Wii, go to GameSpot, 5.8 i say is an extremely accurate rating, its a very old port, tacked on motion controls, no updated graphics when they could be updated, gamespot is right, ign is being bias, with those cold hard facts i just stated there is no way you could give a game like that over 8.
you guys are all probably just saying IGN cause they scored it higher and you like the game, sure its a great game, but its a review compared to its other versions since it is a port, it has so much more potential, but on a console with hardly any good games, sure, its a game youd love
Last edited:
IcedEarth81
WiiChat Member
- Mar 18, 2007
- 208
- 6
If you dislike the Wii so much why are you on a Wii forum? All you've done on here is rundown everything Wii related. I'm not a Nintendo fanboy by any stretch, I owned a PS1 and PS2 exclusively the last two generations, however your dialogue is getting old.
CyanRussel
2062-8990-6509 GET READY!
- Mar 19, 2007
- 1,778
- 17
- Wii Online Code
- 3760-9059-7725-6846
Go to Ign best site to go to!
Oh and scarface is a good game for that matter, i have it at home and i play it more than i play Godfather!
*Shocking*
Oh and scarface is a good game for that matter, i have it at home and i play it more than i play Godfather!
*Shocking*
CyanRussel
2062-8990-6509 GET READY!
- Mar 19, 2007
- 1,778
- 17
- Wii Online Code
- 3760-9059-7725-6846
The Good O'le Golden Days!!!
*:frown2: Hate to say it, But it makes me Cry:sad: , That those days have gone bye-bye!:cryin: *
*:frown2: Hate to say it, But it makes me Cry:sad: , That those days have gone bye-bye!:cryin: *
Shiftfallout
shiftfallout.com
both review sites suck. If you look at gamespot go by the USER REVIEWS and USER RATING. IGN is actually worse than Gamespot. Just understand that if a company slips one of these websites a bit of extra cash, they will get a good review regardless. Thats they type of business they are in.
BDAOutlaw
Smash Elitest
Lol Shift is so right....
User Reviews are the best or maybe you should just look at the Written review predict what score it should get yourself. Ignore the score cause I been thinking Microsoft be slipping money to them sites on a regular not cause of the reviews but cause of GS's top ten list always having so much 360 games on it unlike IGN's which goes by the amount of people veiwing a certain thing.
User Reviews are the best or maybe you should just look at the Written review predict what score it should get yourself. Ignore the score cause I been thinking Microsoft be slipping money to them sites on a regular not cause of the reviews but cause of GS's top ten list always having so much 360 games on it unlike IGN's which goes by the amount of people veiwing a certain thing.
Sovieto
Banned
- Aug 6, 2006
- 6,569
- 91
well i dont know about gamespot but on ign, for all the top 360 games, the user review scores and the site review scores are always very close.BDAOutlaw said:
what 360 games are you talking about? cause your probably just being jealous, cause the only recent m$ published game i can think of is Crackdown...
joe_duffy
Wii gamer, 360 gamer
IGN all the way
BDAOutlaw
Smash Elitest
dunno if you got me or not
but I was just saying that the Top ten list on Gamespot down the bottom has the Majority of the Multi-Platforms under a release for XBOX 360 plus theres the 360 only games
and IMO thats good Advertising for XBOX so they might be slipping them some change.....
but It don't seem like that right now check me in a few....yah im probably jealous my bad
but I was just saying that the Top ten list on Gamespot down the bottom has the Majority of the Multi-Platforms under a release for XBOX 360 plus theres the 360 only games
and IMO thats good Advertising for XBOX so they might be slipping them some change.....
but It don't seem like that right now check me in a few....yah im probably jealous my bad
