Official Graphics Comments & Criticism
- Thread starter ssbb_lover
- Start date
demonflair
Slowly returning..
Here's a sig made for bonodo:
OP
ssbb_lover
Novocain Stain'd
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #619
DUDE, QUIT THE DOUBLE RENDERS, JUST STOP. :lol:demonflair said:Here's a sig made for bonodo:
You're a good sig maker, but you fail in double renders, MOST OF US DO. I'm not picking on you only, i'm safe to say it's true for all of us GFX artists here on Wiichat.
Also the link render isn't good, the bg looks scratchy, and the text isn't good (IMO).
^^ lol, tried to throw the harsh stuff in real quick.
demonflair
Slowly returning..
ssbb_lover said:
When people ask me to do a sig with double renders I do it. But while I'm making the sig I get myself confused with the sig's bg... Then I screw with the sig...
What's wrong with the text??
OP
ssbb_lover
Novocain Stain'd
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #621
Not sure if it's the text itself, or just the fact that it's being squished by 2 renders. >.>demonflair said:
My most recent customer (WiiHoldOnTight) asked to put a hand holding the wiimote, then a broken TV as well. I tried it, didn't like it, presented him with the work that I liked (no broken TV) and he loves it. I know it doesn't seem "customer-friendly", but you should do what YOU think is right for the sig/avvy.
*deposits 2¢*
*EDIT*
And who dropped the rating of this thread to four stars?
Last edited:
demonflair
Slowly returning..
ssbb_lover said:
Sometimes people ask me to do this and I do that, basically I just keep the theme they want in the sig, and then I make it at my own.
And sometimes they ask me to do very hard things, like for example Chain_Blade who told me to make a sig for him with a blade and a spirral chain crossing the blade, I didn't where to get those, and I'm not pretty sure if that would work out.
Brawny
Anglophobiphile
I like the 2nd and 3rd ones. The 1st is great, it's just me who doesn't like that specific color blue.
Halo 3 text might be a little "weird". Read the tutorial on text that I've posted in somewhere. It explains "units" and such. Would be a good read.
Halo 3 text might be a little "weird". Read the tutorial on text that I've posted in somewhere. It explains "units" and such. Would be a good read.
OP
ssbb_lover
Novocain Stain'd
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #626
Hey guys, new sig made for wiiman360.
Leave critique, advice, rude remarks....whatever.
Leave critique, advice, rude remarks....whatever.
OP
ssbb_lover
Novocain Stain'd
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #628
Hmm...ok, thanks. Lemme play around with the color of the bg real quick.Stranger said:
Come back in a bit, i'll edit this post...*EDIT*
O
M
F
G
I saved it as a freakin PNG! Gawd i'm a moron. Whatever, i'll move onto my next sig...
OP
ssbb_lover
Novocain Stain'd
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #630
Good depth, but a bit plain. For n00bs it the aura effect you have going on may distract them form the plain bg, but if you want critique from an honest friend, i'm giving it.
The text blends well, but needs better placement. Border is too thick and I don't like how it fades. Definitely start working on your backgrounds, placement of C4D's (the "aura" effect just looks like a C4D slapped on a layer behind the render, correct me if i'm wrong), and different types of borders (or just round the edges off so you don't need borders).
Regardless, i'd say your best sig yet. :]
The text blends well, but needs better placement. Border is too thick and I don't like how it fades. Definitely start working on your backgrounds, placement of C4D's (the "aura" effect just looks like a C4D slapped on a layer behind the render, correct me if i'm wrong), and different types of borders (or just round the edges off so you don't need borders).
Regardless, i'd say your best sig yet. :]
