Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[ssbb_lover]

Lol, all my sotw 4 entry is c4d/c4d placement/text/adjustments

I noticed, lol. But you incorporated them very professionally.

 

[Brawny]

i have like 10 layers of just overlays/dodge/burn/divide/multiply and I think there's a hue one as well.

 

[demonflair]

Demon, just a think I notice you do with a lot of sigs (not your renderless one), you put the text way too low in your sig and the border cuts it off. You need to put the text higher. :/

I still think that it needs improvements...

And I never did one sig with no render :\

 

[ssbb_lover]

i have like 10 layers of just overlays/dodge/burn/divide/multiply and I think there's a hue one as well.

Brawny, I probably sound like an idiot, but is your user title just for fun or did a mod actually do it? (the "no repping ban" thing)

 

[Brawny]

Just to see if people try to rep me lol

 

[Stranger]

^^ha! great strategy!

 

[ssbb_lover]

Just to see if people try to rep me lol

You S.O.B.! :lol:

 

[Major Tom]

Heres my newest sig. Its VERY dull. But I had a 70kb limit......

 

[Brawny]

whaaaaa/???? Looks like a prinny pic :lol: (that's a good thing)

 

[ssbb_lover]

whaaaaa/???? Looks like a prinny pic :lol: (that's a good thing)

Lol, so true. ^^

What do you guys think about this...

Not my best, but it's my 1st renderless sig...I think this SOTW has forced everyone to do their 1st renderless sig. :lol:

 

[Major Tom]

whaaaaa/???? Looks like a prinny pic :lol: (that's a good thing)

AG (Abstract Gender) is a web-comic I read. I needed a new Banner for my Gaia-Online guild so I made it. I thought it was nice for being only 57kb. (Before I cut its height.)

SSBB LOVER: Nice renderless sig.

 

[ssbb_lover]

SSBB LOVER: Nice renderless sig.

Thank you very much my kind sir.

 

[Stranger]

heres my prototype sotw 4 entry

critique please?

 

[Major Tom]

heres my prototype sotw 4 entry

critique please?

Cool.

 

[ssbb_lover]

Cool.

Great critique.

What I think honestly...is that it's too bland (it's okay for a sig to be plain, but it has to look good, not be bland), double text was a bad idea, you need to learn to make the text work better with the rest of the sig (the color, black, doesn't work 1st off, and on top of that it doesn't blend at all).

One problem that i'm consistently seeing in your sigs is the text. You need to get better at it tbh. :/ Most of the times the sig looks great (like that mushroom one, for instance), but the text ended up killing the rest of the sig.

Perfect practice makes perfect.