Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[gidget]

i hope i impress you guys with my next gimp'd sig for SOTW :yesnod:... i've been hanging on to it in case i think of an idea to add to it

 

[iRAWR]

latest..

its a "meh" IMO

 

[Wii_Smurf]

latest..

its a "meh" IMO

I really like this
You've made an nice fade into the render quite well and the colours are amazing
10/10 for me

 

[Aedus]

Heres one i just did

Needs sharpening.

 

[Aedus]

latest..

its a "meh" IMO

Looks a little flat imo, needs some more depth to it, sharpened effects infront and some blur behind.

Looks a little weird to me, not as good as your current.

 

[manred]

Can you guys and girls give me some opinions on my sig, like things I should do to it to make it better?

 

[gidget]

wow, manred ...this is an awesome sig.

• create another layer of your name
  • make the text a darker color
  • stack it behind your current text layer
  • then anti-alias the original layer a few times
    • this will shave a few pixels off the perimeter of the original name and allow the darker layer to peek around... it'll make the yellow mandred stand-out
  • make sense?
• while you're at it... rotate the name only half as much
  • i.e. instead of -33 degrees, maybe -15 degrees?
    

the sig looks really great, manred :yesnod:... i think iron man has a great guerilla-like effect :yesnod:

is it PS or Gimp?

 

[manred]

I used GIMP for this one and thanks for the tips. I'll try to edit it right now.

 

[gidget]

OH! if convenient, give a slight blur to the background... a setting of 1 or 2 (experiment)
leave ironman sharp

maybe no blur at all on the BG

 

[manred]

Thanks for the tips, you are really good at this.

Edit: Well, there's a problem, I was stupid enough to save it as .jpg rather than .png so I can't edit like anything, so I think I'll just try to create a better one.

 

[gidget]

Thanks for the tips, you are really good at this.

thank you, manred.
i want to read more about Gimp, but i bore easily. :lol:
peeked at a great Gimp book today ($45)... want it, but feel guilty @$45 when there is so much free online info.
i think the book would not bore me, though...

 

[Monsteroids]

My new sig. I made most of the in GIMP and animated the Bear on Flash CS3, it is so easy to draw in Flash.

 

[manred]

thank you, manred.
i want to read more about Gimp, but i bore easily. :lol:
peeked at a great Gimp book today ($45)... want it, but feel guilty @$45 when there is so much free online info.
i think the book would not bore me, though...

I don't know much either because I know more of PS.

Edit: That bear looks pretty awesome Monsteriods, also the sig. Is it really that easy to draw something?

 

[Monsteroids]

I don't know much either because I know more of PS.

Edit: That bear looks pretty awesome Monsteriods, also the sig. Is it really that easy to draw something?

Paintbrush for the outline, Line tool for the shadow outline, and bucket tool for colour.

 

[King Wiired]

Ver 2:

Ver 3: