Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[Star Striker]

Far too long for a sig Demonflair. I just can't be arsed to watch it all.........

 

[Gymdawg]

Meh...

...Never again...

 

[Foxy]

C&C on both please

 

[ssbb_lover]

I could make the 1st in paint, and everyone critiqued your other sig a million years ago...sorry buddy. 2/10

Rick, painfully long...

 

[demonflair]

C&C on both please

1st sig, isn't a sig really... how many layers did you made in that sig, 6??
Those lines are in a bad position, and the circle is in a bad position as well. The font in the text is good though, but the text needs more work. 3.5/10

2nd is alright, the render is small, but you applied it well in the sig, the bg is very plain, a bit boring and doesn't flow at all, it needs some text in there too...
5/10

 

[Syntax]

Demon...

Errrr..

Wasn't that funny...

 

[demonflair]

Demon...

Errrr..

Wasn't that funny...

Damm you people and your non-sense of humor... :sick:


EDIT*

This is going to be my entry for this week's SOTW:

I used this stock:

 

[Close]

I am now going to judge sigs as a sig 'pro' would, not sissy newb stuff.

New sig, please judge harshly:

 

[Syntax]

Text is good..

However I think you overdid the signature with the use of c4d's..

In my opinion its not one of your best..

 

[Close]

Text is good..

However I think you overdid the signature with the use of c4d's..

In my opinion its not one of your best..

Thank You. And the point of this sig, is a style, c4d style, and all you pretty much use is c4ds, and the majority lead to the render. I thought 'Hey, that looks easy!', however it took around an hour to do.

 

[Gymdawg]

I am now going to judge sigs as a sig 'pro' would, not sissy newb stuff.

New sig, please judge harshly:

No light, no depth, no flow, bad color, bad text. Sorry, Close, it's not looking good across the board. Try not to whore the fractals so much. Also, I hate that floating head; it just looks stupid.

 

[Close]

Also, I hate that floating head; it just looks stupid.

Thanks for the advice. I was trying not to do that, but it would've looked really bad. :/

 

[WuddlePook]

Can someone rate my sig? I'm still learning so I need help on what I need to work on.

 

[Syntax]

Its alright.

The text is a bit hard to make our however. Also I'm not a big fan of huge signatures...

 

[Byuakuya]

Byuakuyauyauyauayuayauaya. It's Byuakuya people, if you can't spell it, just highlight, copy, and paste it...

Anyways, Pras, I think you need to start learning how to do more difficult techniques and stray away from the soft sigs that go with your pretty girl renders.

Pretty girl renders. :lol:
Yeah, I will try to do so from now on. Thanks for the tips Tyler.

At Close: It looks good, but I have to agree with Syntax about the over-use of C4Ds.