harry potter

[tommy]

hey everybody i bought the harry potter book and ive finished it now. how many other people have read or are reading it? I wont give away the ending for nobody neither will anyone in this thread

 

[Pikachu256]

I am waiting until my library gets the book in so i don't have to purchase it =]

 

[wii_cammy]

I could give you a pre order I had on it because I bought it at the airport the day it came out and prudly finished it 3 hours later

 

[Brawny]

picked it up saturday, finished it sunday morning (before church, ironically..)

meh, it's good. too much like LOTR TBH. LOTR>HP by a long shot....

Uh...maybe we should have a discussion thread separately, there's a lot of spoiler potential when discussing this...

 

[tommy]

i always thought it was like lotr but without the huge aspect of war fight scenes, not to say there arent duels or anything i just get bored of it saying a flash of red or green light burst from the wand

 

[Brawny]

lol, no one hates comparing the two more than me, but I can't help seeing her stealing ideas.

 

[wii_cammy]

I think Harry Potter is more creaive but that is only my view

 

[Brawny]

you, did. not. just. say. that.

 

[wii_cammy]

Yes. I. Did.

 

[Brawny]

do you know the time tolkien spent on the history of middle earth? the silmarillion was published AFTER his death...what does that tell you? haha

</rant>

ahem, the movies are better too

 

[tommy]

yea all the time he took to creat the names
guess what a mathom is? tolkein made the word up in lotr, i describes something of no use to a hobbit. Thats how keen he was naming little thing like that. I like hp way much but lotr was the best films and books ever on earth for me

 

[wii_cammy]

Yeah its just ive never really caught on to the lotr bandwagon much