Zelda Twilight Princess VS Super Paper Mario

[Link888]

Which game would you rate the highest?

Rate each of the following areas below on both games.
(You can copy the text below and put in your ratings)

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay /10
Graphics /10
Storyline /10
Wii Remote Use /5
Wii Numchuk Use /5
Final Rating /40

Super Paper Mario
Gameplay /10
Graphics /10
Storyline /10
Wii Remote Use /5
Wii Numchuk Use /5
Final Rating /40

After you have rated all the following add your ratings together for you final rating. The game with the highest Final Rating wins.

 

[Secumfex]

I didn't play Super paper mario yet, so I can only rate Zelda TP...

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 7/10
Storyline 9/10 (no-one

Spoiler

dies T_T [except Ganondorf maybe]

)
Wii Remote Use 4/5
Wii Nunchuck Use 3/5
Final Rating 33/40

 

[j4nj1m3n3z]

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 9/10
Storyline 9/10
Wii Remote Use 5/5
Wii Nunchuk Use 3/5
Final Rating 36/40

Super Paper Mario
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 8/10
Storyline 9/10
Wii Remote Use 4/5
Wii Nunchuk Use incomplete
Final Rating 31/35

Zelda Twilight Princess Wins, but Super Paper Mario is close close

 

[wiiman14]

I would say:

loZ: 38/40
Spm: 29/35

 

[ericlewis91]

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 8/10
Storyline 10/10
Wii Remote Use 3/5
Wii Nunchuk Use 4/5
Final Rating 36/40

Super Paper Mario
Gameplay 6/10
Graphics 5/10
Storyline 6/10
Wii Remote Use 4/5
Wii Nunchuk Use incomplete
Final Rating 21/35

 

[Wade]

They're both great games in their own right.

 

[+Maniacal=Maniac+]

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 9/10
Storyline 10/10
Wii Remote Use 5/5
Wii Nunchuk Use 3/5
Final Rating 36/40

Super Paper Mario
Gameplay 8/10
Graphics 8/10
Storyline 10/10
Wii Remote Use 3/5
Wii Nunchuk Use 0/5
Final Rating 29/40



Eh... Paper Mario Got PWNED By TP...

 

[Mr. person]

tlp as highest rating there can be

spm not very high because its super short but it is a good game

 

[Rosbaughcr]

Super Paper Mario is very short (longer if you complete the pit of trials, but still short), compared to Zelda. Super Paper Mario is also more linear and less difficult. People enjoy both, but I hear people praise Zelda as the best Wii game frequently. Personally, I thought Super Paper Mario was too short (I recommend renting it) and I am not a big Zelda franchise fan.

 

[Link888]

Thanx for your replys ppl but please try to rate the games.

 

[Monsteroids]

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 9/10 Everything works, and just plain cool, nothing outstanding yet though

Graphics 8/10 a few cutsene bugs tha i've seen GC port but has the Zelda scenery and Link looks pretty badass a solid 8

Storyline 9/10 Saving two princesses and your gilfriend now! Links good with the girls, ey? Really imersive my friend, REALLY!

Wii Remote Use 2/5 A, A, A, point n click, A mmmm..... Sword slashes are not impressive, a 2.

Wii Nunchuk Use 3/5 constant use of those buttons but no motion a 4

Quirk: badass look, awesome story, and its ZELDA!!! totally 5/5!!!

Downside: GC port, non-revolutionary gameplay and the wolf gets old9no points were deducted cuz of the wolf) -3/-5
Final Rating 33/40

Super Paper Mario

Gameplay 9/10 for an rpg it plays well and the 3d thing is amusing
nothing wrong with the mechanics iin my opinion sensitivity is fine

Graphics 10/10 a very crisp and amusing 2d beauty

Storyline 6/10 hmmm... the plot is unoriginal, childish, short, but no fear Marios here

Wii Remote Use 4/5 youre always using it and the cusor is used in a lot of places too

Wii Nunchuk Use 0/5 no need

Quirk: funny, good look, Cute, funny, Mario and the gang, a fine paper mario sequel 4/5

Downfall:Short and too easy -3/-5

Final Rating 30/40

The extra bits are completly my own opinion. Results without my opinion.
TP: 31 (-2)
PM:29 (-1)

 

[demonflair]

I can't rate Paper Mario, because it's not out in Europe...

Twilight Princess:

Gameplay 9/10, in overall is very good, actually great, like always, but it could have used the Wiimote and Numchuk even more.
Graphics 9/10, possibly the best graphics on the Wii so far..
Storyline 10/10, Perfect!!!
Wii Remote Use 3/5, I was expecting more of this game with the Wiimote.
Wii Numchuk Use 3/5, same as above
Final Rating 34/40

 

[powpowpow]

Zelda Twilight Princess
Gameplay 10/10
Graphics 9/10
Storyline 10/10
Wii Remote Use 5/5
Wii Nunchuk Use 3/5
Final Rating 36/40

Your ratings are ridiculous.
I'd elaborate but it would just be wasted on you.

 

[Monsteroids]

Your ratings are ridiculous.
I'd elaborate but it would just be wasted on you.

huh?

 

[demonflair]

Your ratings are ridiculous.
I'd elaborate but it would just be wasted on you.